Blog / Articles

Comparing Salt And Sand For Ice: Which Is The Right Choice?

salt or sand for ice

When winter arrives and ice starts to cover the streets and driveways, homeowners and municipalities turn to two common solutions – salt or sand for ice. While these remedies have been traditional go-to options to combat the freezing temperatures and slippery surfaces, they come with their share of drawbacks. This article aims to compare these two solutions, touching upon their effects on our environment, roads, vehicles, pets, concrete, and plants, and introduces an innovative alternative – Safe Paw.

Get ready for winter with the ONLY Pet Safe Ice Melt you can trust


The Case for Salt

Salt, often sourced from a road salt supply, is a popular choice due to its ability to lower the freezing point of water. This reaction helps to melt ice and prevents it from forming on roads and driveways. However, the usage of salt comes with a multitude of negatives.

Eco Friendly Ice Melt

Safe Paw - Ice Melt For Concrete Driveways

Safe Paw

The Original and the #1 Pet and Child Safe Ice Melt for over 20 years. Guaranteed environmentally safe – will not harm waterways and sensitive wetlands.

Firstly, salt can be incredibly harmful to both pets and the environment. When ingested, it can lead to health issues in pets, including irritation, dehydration, and in extreme cases, sodium poisoning. Its impact on the environment is equally concerning. Salt runoff can infiltrate groundwater, contaminate waterways, and harm aquatic life. It can also damage soil, inhibiting the growth of plants.

Secondly, salt can cause significant damage to property and infrastructure. It can corrode concrete, deteriorate roads, and even harm vehicles by causing rust and corrosion.

Get ready for winter with the ONLY Pet Safe Ice Melt you can trust

The Case for Sand

Sand, on the other hand, doesn’t melt ice but provides traction on slippery surfaces, reducing the likelihood of accidents. However, like salt, sand too has its cons.

Primarily, sand contributes to air and water pollution. Fine particles can become airborne when vehicles pass over, impacting air quality. It also often ends up in storm drains, contributing to sediment build-up and impacting local water quality.

The Superior Alternative: Safe Paw

In light of the drawbacks associated with both salt and sand for ice, an alternative is necessary. Safe Paw, a chemical-free, toxin-free ice melt, emerges as a superior choice. Here’s why:

Get ready for winter with the ONLY Pet Safe Ice Melt you can trust

  • Safe for Pets and Environment: Unlike traditional ice melts, Safe Paw is safe for pets even if ingested and doesn’t harm the environment. It won’t contaminate waterways or negatively impact plant growth.
  • Does Not Damage Property or Infrastructure: Safe Paw is safe for use on concrete, causing no corrosion or deterioration. It doesn’t harm vehicles or infrastructure, a clear advantage over traditional road salt supply options.
  • Effective Ice Melt: Despite being toxin-free, Safe Paw is highly effective at melting ice, providing a slip-free environment in winter conditions.

Gaia Enterprises Inc. delivers 100% pet-safe and environmentally friendly winter products. Safe Paw, our flagship product, is the #1 selling pet-safe ice melt that does not harm pets, safe if ingested, and safe on all types of concrete.


While many people might rely on their local road salt supply or bags of sand to combat icy conditions, these options can have harmful effects on pets, the environment, and our infrastructure. The keyword when dealing with icy conditions should not be just “salt or sand for ice,” but rather “what is safe and effective for melting ice?”

Safe Paw offers an answer to that question. Its chemical-free, toxin-free formula provides an effective, environmentally friendly, and pet-safe ice melt solution that minimally impacts infrastructure. As we navigate icy conditions, it is important to remember that the choices we make can have far-reaching effects. Opting for products like Safe Paw ensures that we are taking a step in the right direction, for our immediate surroundings and for the environment as a whole.

Get ready for winter with the ONLY Pet Safe Ice Melt you can trust

Try Our Other Winter Safety Products

Walk On Ice

Prevent slips at home, work or on the go, The handy disposable canister can be taken everywhere, with the same 100% naturally occurring minerals that provide instant traction on ice or snow.

Walk On Ice - Traction On Ice

Traction Magic

Stay safe on slippery surfaces with a product that’s 100% natural and safe for pets, people, and your property. Use Traction Magic on sidewalks, steps, or as instant traction for your car.

Traction Magic Concrete Safe Ice Melt

Become A Safe Paw Distributor

Bulk Purchase With Safe Paw

    Become A Safe Paw Distributor

      Buy Now On Amazon